Will we have Civil War in Britain?

The answer to rhetorical questions such as this at the head of newspaper articles is almost always ‘No’. However, David Betz, a Professor of War in the Modern World at Kings College London, predicts there is a nearly 20% chance of civil war in the UK in the next five years. [1]

A Civil War is defined as a conflict between two or more belligerents who at the beginning of the conflict were under the same sovereign authority. To be clear a British civil war would not be the kind we had in the 1640’s: Roundheads v Cavaliers with pitched battles like Edghill. It would be more like the ‘troubles’ in Northern Ireland in the 1980’s.

A civil war would develop slowly. There is a ‘classical model’ of insurgency that was developed by Chairman Mao:

Stage 1: the defensive phase. (From the perspective of the insurgents)

The insurgents identify a set of common grievances and build a collective identity around a story. They build a political organisation to work on propaganda.

 They organise for defence and may build alliances with criminal groups who will probably have more access to weapons.

This stage may last 5, 10 or 50 years.

Stage 2: Stalemate

Attacks have begun to occur but the insurgents have less firepower than the government. They can though create no-go areas and start to build military structures. They can ambush police stations and attack judges, media figures etc.

They try to provoke the government to overreact, so that more moderate citizens become radicalized. Sanctions against the moderates are typically seen as elite overreach. This leads to a collapse of trust in the government .

Stage 3: Offensive phase

The government has weakened to the extent that insurgents can launch terrorist style attacks on police and the military. Assassinations occur. Urban versus rural conflicts may break out. Revered icons get destroyed. Major city’s infrastructure such as hospitals, bridges and schools can be severely threatened.

The CIA has a similar model where the 3 stages are called ‘pre-insurgency’, ‘incipient conflict’ and ‘open insurgency’. [2]

What stage are we in?

David Betz reckons we are in the early stages of stage 2 where the principal insurgents are Islamists. But there could be several other factions such as ‘eco-warriers’ and ‘decolonisers’.

The evidences of phase 1 are

a) the increase in immigration in the last 30 years with the establishment of ‘multiculturalism’.[3]

b) the increase in the number of mosques eg 35 in Leicester alone.[4]

c) the systematic rape of young white girls by Islamists. [5]

d) the putative definition of ‘Islamophobia’ as ‘racist’ for attitudes against ‘perceived muslimness’.[6]

e) protests against perceived ‘anti-Islam’ insults eg) where a teacher is still in hiding after several years after allegedly showing a cartoon of the prophet Mohammed [7]

f) There are 40-50,000 people on the UK terror watch list predominantly within minority ethnic groups. [8]

The evidences of phase 2 are

a) the possible infiltration of Islamists into local government and civil service [9]

b) the election of ethnic Muslim MPs one of whom has advocated a blasphemy law to support the ‘Abrahamic religions'[10]

c) the establishment of no-go areas and sharia courts in cities with large minority Muslim populations.[11]

d) occasional Islamic terrorist attacks eg London Bridge attack [12]

e) occasional ‘decolonisation’ of public monuments [13] and works of art [14]

f) Muslim and ‘far right’ factions in riots.[15]

g) pro-Gaza demonstrations in big cities [16].

h) government condemnation of the concerned native population as ‘far right’. [17]

i) The anti-radicalisation organisation Prevent has added “people who think that western cultures are at risk from other cultures” to their potential terrorist watchlist.[18]

j) the apparent concentration of police time and effort on thoughts and tweets rather than physical crimes.[19]

k) In London over 1000 ULEZ cameras have been vandalised.[20]

What are the chances of a Civil War?

The chances of a stage 3 civil war in the UK is reckoned at about 4% per annum. This is equivalent to an 18% chance in the next 5 years.

The chances of a civil war are increased by the emergence of factions, ie. groups of persons forming a cohesive minority within the society based on ethnic, religious or geographic lines. [21] At the current time the most likely emergent factions in the UK are Islamism, the extreme radical version of Islam that calls for jihad (holy war), and the titular British majority who feel their culture is being downgraded [18]. Downgrading is a technical term in civil war theory where a dominant group goes from being able to decide what language is spoken, whose laws are enforced and whose culture is revered to a situation where they do not. [1] Factionalisation of this kind could draw moderates on both sides to more radical views [22].

A further incentive towards civil war is where the government is perceived to have lost its legitimacy ie it no longer serves the people. The government then has to enforce its directives more forcefully on a populace that have hitherto been compliant even when they didn’t agree because they could see that the decisions had been arrived at according to the rules.. When the government has healthy finances they can possibly buy their way out of trouble by concessions and subsidies but this becomes more and more unfeasible as time progresses.

The UK is generally reckoned to be ‘multicultural’ at this time. It is instructive to try to understand the cultures we have in the UK and thus seek to prevent the deterioration towards civil war.

Family Structures

The sociological theory promoted by Emmanuel Todd (b1951) [24] claims that culture comes from how families are organised. [23] There is a strong correlation between the form of governance of a nation and its consequent stability and the kind of family structures prevalent in the nation. The controversial claim is that family structures determine political structures or at least influence them.

The theory recognises eight different family structures across the world. I will discuss those most relevant here. For those living in any one of these structures it would be hard to conceive of anything different.

The traditional English (Anglo Saxon) family structure is known as the Absolute Nuclear Family. It is prevalent in England and the former English colonies and also in the Netherlands and Denmark. In these countries people marry for love, their children move away from the family home when they reach the age of maturity. Parents divide their inheritance how they like usually equally among their offspring.

The children are expected to make their own way in the world. Hence the individual is responsible for their own conduct and success. Thus billionaires are tolerated as they are seen to have done well for themselves. Since families disperse people turn to churches clubs etc to find friends. The countries with this family structure were the first countries to have multiparty democracies and religious freedom. Freedom is seen as senior to equality. The dominant ideology is liberal capitalism and revolutions are rare. The political structures in these countries are generally stable.

The Absolute Nuclear Family is under pressure in the UK partly because of economic mismanagement and changing sexual mores. For example, around 1 in every 4.5 families (22.4%) have an adult child living in the same house. [25] About 25% of families are single parent families, mostly single mother families (90%) [26]. 25% of all pregnancies are aborted [27]. The fertility rate (children per woman) is 1.44 [28] well below the population maintenance rate of 2.1. This is a demographic time bomb.

By contrast in the Authoritarian Family structure the eldest son inherits the entire estate and there is consequently a virtually indestructible lineage. The other offspring tend to end up in the priesthood or military. Inequality is thus seen as natural. The English aristocracy tend to practice this system. It is common in Scandinavia, Germany, Korea and Japan, and also in Scotland and Ireland. Todd says these countries have a deep sense of history and nationalism to the point where they are willing to sacrifice themselves for their country. This can lead to tyrannical governments. Since the family is broken up at each generation these countries tend to have large middle classes.

Although England and Scotland have these two separate systems (to some degree intermingled since the act of Union) it is not too difficult for them to live together these days despite strong Scottish nationalism.

A third family structure, perhaps more relevant to the current discussion, is known as the Endogamous Communitarian. In this system people marry inside their clan generally through arranged marriages quite often between cousins. Everyone in the family knows everyone else and lives under the same roof. There is generally not much tension in the household and so the grandfather figure is not dominant. Since the women are cousins and sisters they are taken care of and protected by their male relatives but they are not equal to the men. The clan is governed by a council of males. This system is practised mostly in Islamic societies, the middle east, north Africa and Pakistan. Todd observes that such societies are horrible to outsiders and for much of history practised slavery.

Referencing the evidences of incipient civil war above, we see that the tension in society is caused by the clash of two systems at least exemplified if not caused by two different family structures. Not all cultures are the same. Diversity is not our strength. The question is what to do about it. Most of this is at the government level perhaps ultimately at the ballot box, if political parties recognise the danger and adopt a rational approach.

How to avert a Civil War

James Fearon studied which features of democarcy were important in averting civil war. He found three features

a) “the rule of law” (the equal and impartial application of legal procedure);

b) “voice and accountability” (the extent to which citizens are able to participate in selecting their government, as well as freedom of expression, freedom of association, and a free media); and

c) “government effectiveness” (the quality of public services and the quality and independence of the civil service). [29]

All three of these aspects of government require attention as can be seen from the evidences of incipient civil war mentioned above.

a) Rule of Law

There have been numerous rumblings that the law is being applied unequally A recent set of guidelines for sentencing criminals was withdrawn after it was widely seen as favoring certain minorities. What was not remarked upon was the very existence of the‘Sentencing Council for England and Wales’ which had produced the guidelines independent of government and which had initially refused to withdraw them. [30] “Rule of Law” must not degenerate into “Rule of Lawyers”.

“Two Tier Policing” and all perception of such must be addressed and eradicated.

b) Voice and Accountability

Free Speech must be promoted as a British value. People who say the wrong thing should not be ‘cancelled’. [31] As the slogan of the Free Speech Union [32] says

“If liberty means anything at all it means the right to tell people what they do not want to hear” – George Orwell [33]

c) Government Effectiveness

Government has been devolved to ‘experts’ in quangos which are unaccountable to the electorate. The civil service is seen as following its own agenda independent of the elected government. This must be rectified.

Apart from the ballot box and the hope that the government might get a grip on all this, there is the question of what individuals can do if the worst comes to the worst and civil war does break out.

The main thing is not to live in a city, as cities are particularly vulnerable to sabotage of electrical, water, gas and food supplies. There are also more targets for looting and more people to get upset with each other. Find a safe haven. Prepare as best you can.

References

[1] https://www.militarystrategymagazine.com/article/civil-war-comes-to-the-west/

[2] Walter, Barbara F.. How Civil Wars Start: And How to Stop Them (p. 156). Penguin Books Ltd. Kindle Edition.

[3] https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/culturalidentity/religion/bulletins/religionenglandandwales/census2021

[4] https://tovisorga.com/leicester/how-many-mosques-are-there-in-leicester/

[5] https://thecritic.co.uk/the-grooming-gangs-scandal-shows-the-importance-of-free-speech

[6] https://www.camden.gov.uk/documents/20142/4794543/APPG+Definition+of+Islamophobia.pdf

[7] https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/1743624/Teacher-in-hiding-prophet-Mohammed-cartoon-Batley-Grammar-School-West-Yorkshire

[8] https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8450211/MI5s-terror-watchlist-doubles-43-000-just-one-year.html (23/6/2020)

[9] https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2016/may/02/inside-ricu-the-shadowy-propaganda-unit-inspired-by-the-cold-war

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2025/06/24/home-office-worker-granted-asylum-applications-for-money

https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/civil-service-staff-networks/civil-service-muslim-network

[10] https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/2024-11-27/debates/5CDC74BA-B602-4676-A97A-B678AF436F85/Engagements#contribution-70F53BD1-31B1-4084-8E03-E774F00AF150

[11] https://www.gatestoneinstitute.org/5177/no-go-zones-britain

[12] https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-40147164

[13] https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2024/05/05/blade-runners-fell-ulez-cameras-after-khans-re-election/

[14] https://www.standard.co.uk/news/uk/all-artworks-just-stop-oil-attacked-b1038844.html

[15] https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2024/08/04/far-right-and-muslims-clash-fresh-riots-bolton/

[16] https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/ce3wzpjj770o

[17] https://www.lbc.co.uk/news/sir-keir-starmer-sparks-backlash-blames-far-right-grooming-gang-inquiry/

[18] https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2025/06/06/concern-over-mass-migration-terrorist-ideology-prevent/

[19] https://news.sky.com/story/couple-arrested-after-school-whatsapp-chat-messages-say-they-cannot-fathom-what-happened-13337935

[20] https://www.rac.co.uk/drive/news/motoring-news/met-police-reveal-nearly-1000-ulez-cameras-have-been-stolen-or-damaged/

[21] Walter, Barbara F.. How Civil Wars Start: And How to Stop Them (p. 214). Penguin Books Ltd. Kindle Edition.

[22] https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/cameron-my-war-on-multiculturalism-2205074.html

[23] https://behappyfamily.com/how-ideology-is-influenced-by-family-structure.html

[24] Emmanuel Todd (1985) The explanation of Ideology, Family Structures and Social Systems. transl David Garrioch , Blackwell (unavailable on line and apparently out of print see [23]) See also Joseph Henrich (2021)“The Wierdest People in the World” Penguin

[25] https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/populationandmigration/populationestimates/articles/moreadultslivingwiththeirparents/2023-05-10

[26] https://www.gingerbread.org.uk/our-work/single-parents-facts-and-figures/

[27] https://www.johnstonsarchive.net/policy/abortion/ab-unitedkingdom.html

[28] https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cnvj3j27nmro

[29] Walter, Barbara F.. How Civil Wars Start: And How to Stop Them (p. 200). Penguin Books Ltd. Kindle Edition.

[30] https://www.ft.com/content/c5c6bc7d-bf1b-48cd-9453-63d8adb30fa2

[31] https://www.msn.com/en-gb/news/uknews/school-that-took-girl-out-of-class-for-wearing-union-jack-dress-closes-after-receiving-extremist-abuse/ar-AA1IRm0K

[32] https://freespeechunion.org/

[33] George Orwell “ Orwell’s Proposed Preface to Animal Farm” 1945 Published: in The Times Literary Supplement, 15 September 1972

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *